AW: Authz permisison problem after upgrade from 1.6.16 to 1.7.1

No. IMHO this is a bug.

If I have some time, I will try to provide an test setup.

I can't post our current repo for obvious reasons J

Von: Bostjan Skufca [mailto:bostjan_at_a2o.si]
Gesendet: Samstag, 12. November 2011 03:21
An: Jens Geyer
Cc: users_at_subversion.apache.org
Betreff: Re: Authz permisison problem after upgrade from 1.6.16 to 1.7.1

Hi Jens,

did you get this resolved somehow already?

b.

On 10 November 2011 17:09, Jens Geyer <jgx_at_vsx.net> wrote:

Hi *,

I have an really interesting case here, which looks to me like an bug.

The behavior started after the upgrade of our SVN server from 1.6.16 to
1.7.1.
We use a windows server (SVNSERVE) here, I haven't tested this on
Apache.

The scenario:
We have a source code tree, which lives let's say under

       /trunk/testApp

In the SVN root, we have some more folders, such as

       /branches

We also have a build server, who checks the source out into his local
WC.
After the successful build, the build server sets an tag under

       /tags/buildserver/testApp

Which he does by means of svn copy (I can provide the exact command, if
neceassary).
This works, if I configure the access control file like this:

       [/tags]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

       [/trunk]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

        [/]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

It does no longer work (the svn copy command fails with "access denied")
when I add /branches to the access configuration:

       [/tags]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

       [/trunk]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

       [/branches]
       * = r

        [/]
       Buildserver = rw
       * = r

It starts to work again, if I give the buildserver explicit write
access to [/branches].

==> Please note, that /branches is not affected by the copy, neither as
source, nor as the target.
==> This looks like a clear bug to me.

Again, I were not able to found any documentation about such changes in
the access control logic.
Is there some documentation around about these new "features" of svn
1.7?

JensG

 
Received on 2011-11-14 09:48:40 CET