[svn.haxx.se] · SVN Dev · SVN Users · SVN Org · TSVN Dev · TSVN Users · Subclipse Dev · Subclipse Users · this month's index

Re: Let's discuss about unicode compositions for filenames!

From: Peter Samuelson <peter_at_p12n.org>
Date: Mon, 30 Jan 2012 09:22:11 -0600

  [Stefan Sperling]
> > We could also open the parent directory, read all the filenames
> > within it, normalise them all, and then search the resulting
> > list. This works, expect if a name exists twice, once in NFC form
> > and once in NFD form. We'd somehow have to solve the name collision
> > in the filesystem.

[Markus Schaber]
> This sounds astonishingly similar to the lower/upper case problem of
> UN*X vs. Mac/Win.

There are similarities, but there are some important differences:

- We have to support Mac OS X, which stores all files in NFD. In the
  upper/lowercase analogy, think of OS X as MS-DOS, which does not
  preserve mixed case at all but always represents files in uppercase.
  Subversion doesn't support MS-DOS and I hope we never need to. MS
  Windows, OTOH, at least preserves the upper/lowercase distinction
  presented to it when you create a file. Big difference.

  (I'm not saying OS X is like MS-DOS in other respects. Just for the
  purpose of the NFC/NFD vs. upper/lower analogy.)

- Also, the Subversion platform has chosen to support files like README
  and Readme that conflict on Windows. Our reasoning is "if you have
  users on Windows, don't do that." Most solutions to the NFC/NFD
  problem will affect all platforms, not just one, and we probably
  can't just say "well, don't do that" - we'll need to actually prevent
  it - and somehow deal with existing clients, WCs, and repositories).

Because of those differences, my gut feeling is that we can't treat the
two issues in the same way.

Peter
Received on 2012-01-30 16:22:57 CET

This is an archived mail posted to the Subversion Dev mailing list.