Jeff Smith wrote:
> On Thursday 11 January 2007 13:45, Jeff Smith wrote:
>> I think the major problem lyes in what exactly is an object. When
>> copying "/trunk/prj1/" to "/tags/prj1_1/", is the new one the same
>> object? Of course not. If an object gets moved from "/trunk/" to
>> "/trunk/prj2/", is the latter the same object as the first? No.
> I'd better add quickly that I read your original post again, and I
> agree with you completely, that there should be an easier way to see
> that "file.txt" has been deleted, when only looking at that file's
> I also agree with everyone else 100%. The detail that I think you
> should accept concerning displaying log entry for "-r1234" (in which
> "file.txt" no longer exists) is that the file no longer exists there.
> I guess they just couldn't think of any way to show the deletion of
> that file except by looking at the containing folder, and I can't
> think of one either. If you have any solutions yet, we'd like to hear
> It's just that I agree we should not be able to see "some/file.txt" in
> -r1234, because it simply does not exist in that state (revision 1234
> of the tree).
A log is a history and a history is not at state nor a collection
of states. Humor me for a moment...
If we were talking about "svn info", "svn update", or other
"state" tools I'd agree. But we're talking about "svn log" which
is a history tool. -As I noted in another post, if it was a
state tool it couldn't accept ranges like -r10:20 much like svn
info can not.
But I think it matters not. I'm of the mind now that the way to
move forward is not to mess with the current results svn log
produces (no matter what I think of them), but instead to expand
the svn log command to offer a new syntax for such things:
svn log -r10:20 path@ALL
Results in the history of path between revs 10 and 20
inclusive, irregardless of peg version changes or
svn log --action A path@ALL
Results in all log entries where path was Added,
regardless of the peg versions.
svn log --action D path@1234
Results in the single log entry which notes path being
deleted (or replaced) for peg version (ie object) 1234.
To match current SVN nomenclature 1234 must be a rev
of the object at a state when it did exist. In the
above example it might return the log for r4567 if that
was the log which describes the Deletion of 1234.
svn log path@ALL
The entire history of path from the first Add to the
last Deletion and everything in between, irregardless
of the peg version or the existence of a peg version.
In other words "ALL" really, truly, means "ALL,
Everything, Give it to me I can handle it baby, yah!"
I'm starting to work on coding this up in svn to see how well
it might function in practice.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
For additional commands, e-mail: email@example.com
Received on Fri Jan 12 05:30:22 2007