On Tue, Jun 01, 2004 at 12:35:05PM -0700, firstname.lastname@example.org wrote:
> I've occasionally heard people talk about VC
> systems based on the "deck of cards" paradigm
> - where you locked several particular regions,
> basically line numbers, typically scaled up
> to procedures, etc., of the source.
The "Delta Line Editor" (at Bell Labs) was one of the more
famous ones. It was used to VC a large telecom switching
program that was written in assembly language. One could
checkout/checkin at the granularity of lines, and line
Then in the late 80s and early 90s when CASE was hot, there
were some CASE tools (like ProCase and SmartCase), often for
Ada, that would allow logical (rather than physical) units of
fine-grained checkout such as procedure/method, data definition,
And of course in the Smalltalk world, with environments like
VisualWorks and tools like ENVY/Developer, it was the norm to be
able to checkin/checkout at the level of a method, or a class.
These days, fine-grained locking tends to try and apply to logical
elements rather than a line-range. It is becoming "en vogue" again
from two different drivers:
2. Formal Requirements Traceability
As Model Driven Development/Architecture becomes more popular,
there is a desire to be able to use the model and the modeling
elements within it (instead of the file-system) as the way of
navigating thru the source code. E.g.:
- open up a particular model
- double-click on a UML "package" to "zoom in"
- then "double click" on a class to drill-down to its
- then double-click again to drill-down on the appropriate
subclass, and see an expanded list of its methods and
- then double-click on the method signature to view its
source-code, and then decide if you want to checkout
the code and modify it.
This is of course reminiscent of some CASE tool functionality.
Imagine a "plug-in" between the modeling tool and Eclipse to
enable this sort of thing. And the modeling tool takes care of
mapping modeling elements to files (with the help of some
customizable project preference settings), as well as tracing
logical build/link/execution dependencies between modeling
elements and files (and other modeling elements).
I think this is the sort of thing the Eclipse Stellation project
had in mind (see http:www.eclipse.org/stellation)
2. Formal Requirements Traceability
"Hi Tier" Requirements development+traceability tools (like
Telelogic DOORS, or Rational RequisitePro) are becoming much
more desirable than manual traceability matrix creation/updating
for projects that mandate full formal requirements traceability.
Basically it lets you "edit" a document where each
"paragraph" is really an "object" in a database that can
be separately versioned from the others, and that can have
attributes (properties) and or links to any other object in
the repository. links can be added (and attributed) between
related requirements "objects", or between a requirement
"object" and its corresponding objects it was decomposed into
in a lower-level requirements document and/or a design document.
Imagine for a moment if someone provided some kind of GUI
editing environment for editing all the files in a particular
directory of a subversion repository as if they were really a
sequence of contiguous text sections in a single document. I
could still do operations like search/replace/format across
the entire document (all files in the directory) but could
also checkout/checkin (and lock :) either the entire document
and/or a particular "paragraph" that was really just a single
file within the director, but which the GUI environment made
it look as if it was a logical portion of a larger "artifact"
that I could edit as a "whole".
For current state of the art and an opensource project (that
is part of the Eclipse Tools project), I recommend interested
parties take a peek at the "Stellation" project:
*** The Stellation project: Advanced SCM for Collaboration
It's actually pretty interesting IMHO. They have their own notion of
"lightweight branching" that is worth comparing to SVN.
Brad Appleton <email@example.com> www.bradapp.net
Software CM Patterns (www.scmpatterns.com)
Effective Teamwork, Practical Integration
"And miles to go before I sleep." -- Robert Frost
To unsubscribe, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
For additional commands, e-mail: email@example.com
Received on Wed Jun 2 08:49:11 2004