On Wed, 28 Sep 2005, Julian Foad wrote:
> Peter N. Lundblad wrote:
> > [Note to other committers: I'm going to replace the existing DTDs with RNC
> > schemas if no one objects.]
> I object until I see a consensus for getting rid of the DTDs.
Good, you object until you see a concensus and there can be no consensus
until you stop objecting:-) Seriously, I don't see the point of keeping
the DTDs when they can be generated automatically.
> Would you care to point me in the direction of a program that I can use
> instead of "xmllint" (which I've been using for DTDs) to check data
> against RNCs? Preferably one that's available as a SuSE Linux RPM.
You can use jing (see thaiopensource.com), or you can even use xmllint
--relaxng. The latter only support the XML syntax, but you can use trang
> By all means add RNCs, though if we're going to have more than one kind of
> DTD/schema then it would be nice if there were one master format and an
> auto-conversion to any other formats.
That's the point of the previous mail in this thread (but I realize that
maybe you didn't follow this (recurring) discussion until my "stimulator
> >>If you only store the .rnc file in the repository, how do you propose
> >>users get the XSD/DTD files? Can the trang tool you mention be added to
> >>the official build procedure?
> > It could, but only if trang is available. Adding that as a required
> > dependency isn't an option, of course. But then it is pretty easy to run
> > trang yourself. Would it be enough if we documented (in the FAQ?) how to
> > get other chema languages from the .rnc files?
> I think if we made it easy, e.g. by providing a Makefile target that would do
> it if "trang" is installed, might be sufficient. It's not unreasonable to
> expect XML developers to install an XML utility like "trang".
that's OK with me. Do we want to make it even easier and add them to the
release tarballs? It's another (small) burden on the RM.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
For additional commands, e-mail: email@example.com
Received on Thu Sep 29 09:09:31 2005