On Jul 13, 2005, at 10:29 AM, nick vajberg wrote:
> In general, I'd like the logging facility to be
> independent of server. That is, logging should work
> the same way whether running httpd or svnserve or
> something else.
It's funny that this thread came up, because over in Collabnet, we're
thinking about the same problem. We'd like to add some "high level"
logging to mod_dav_svn, because it turns out that simply reading the
apache accesslog isn't enough. It's a side effect of using WebDAV/
DeltaV. At most, you can see that a user was doing some reads or
writes. But, for example, 'svn checkout/update/switch/export/blame/
log/diff/merge' all look like a single REPORT request. Pretty useless.
The patch that Karl and I sent to the list in which the client
'declares' what it's doing was shot down, and rightfully so. Forget
about it. That leaves us only one avenue left: add new code to
mod_dav_svn to deduce and log client operations. For example,
mod_dav_svn already understands the 7 different types of HTTP REPORT
requests, so it can easily write to a log that "so-and-so did an
update", "so-and-so did a blame", etc.
I've been pondering ways to make svnserve and mod_dav_svn share as
much logging-code as possible, but the situation seems to be a bit grim.
In an ideal world, the different server implementations would only
ever call libsvn_repos, and then the logging ability could be
silently buried into all of svn_repos.h APIs. But we're not in the
ideal world. Our different server implementations call a mixture of
libsvn_repos and libsvn_fs functions, and they call them at different
times and in different ways. There's almost no shared logic at all.
I guess it's not surprising, since one server is doing a stateful
protocol, the other stateless.
So I think that the most we can hope for are some new svn_repos.h
APIs to make it "easier" for a server to write logs. At most, we can
work to guarantee that mod_dav_svn and svnserve produce logs that
look similar. I'm thinking of APIs like:
- open/close a logfile
- write a client-action into a logfile
- write a debugging string into a logfile
I'd love to discuss/design these APIs.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: email@example.com
For additional commands, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Received on Thu Jul 14 18:13:31 2005